The New York Times reports that college students, tired of paying top dollar for required textbooks, have begun to scan and upload their textbooks to file sharing networks. For years, textbook manufacturers have held somewhat of a unique monopoly over students, charging hundreds of dollars for books required by professors.
One student has scanned his $210 Organic Chemistry textbook in to PDF format and uploaded it to the file sharing website Piratebay.org. Organized chapter by chapter, peers are able to download each section needed and print out copies of assigned readings whenever they wish. What’s interesting is that the student did not do all of this to make a profit, but rather to avenge himself and other students who are tired of being “ripped off” by the textbook industry.
Experts are concerned that textbooks may go the way of the compact disc: subsumed by file sharing technology. Not only are college students typically technically capable of downloading textbooks online, but they are also the population segment mainly associated with downloading infringing content.
Publishers often issue new editions of their texts every year or so, and compensate professors who choose to offer their texts with free copies or other teaching materials. This often leaves students with hundreds of dollars worth of textbook expenses each semester. Students typically can only sell back their textbooks for only a fraction of the price paid just a few months earlier.
Intellectual property theorists often describe college textbooks as one of the last heavily protected mediums to succumb to digitalization. Monopolistic protection of texts also remains strong due the collegiate culture involving textbooks. Students are rarely given an option when it comes to choosing which textbooks to use. Since professors are not burdened by the cost of an expensive text, students are left to foot the bill.
Textbook publishers are beginning to respond to the trend, often publishing additional supplemental material online and making it only available to legitimate purchasers who register their texts. Aspen Publishing, one of the leading publishers of legal casebooks, is now beginning to offer digital editions of its books available for purchase on its website. While mainly limited to supplemental materials like “Emanuel Law Outlines,” the digital editions often cost just as much as the printed editions sold in bookstores. This pricing structure gives users little incentive to choose a digital format, especially when the digital editions cannot be sold after the end of a course.
While students who upload their scanned textbooks may feel like modern-day Robin Hoods, little hope seems to be on the horizon for students wishing to pay less for books each semester. Not only has the publishing industry been slow in adopting digital formats, it also is increasing surveillance of file sharing networks, and has begun taking legal action against infringers. Until Steve Jobs decides to open up the iTunes Textbook store, college students will have to continue to have to pay top dollar for textbooks.